The Lensmaster Lounge

Where lensmasters know best. W00t.

submit a bug report

You are not logged in.

Announcement

*The Forum Rules.

Yep, rules. Read 'em. Abide by 'em. Or your sea creature powers may be revoked. Temporarily, or for good.

1. New to the lounge? Get started here. Learn which category to post your note in, and create a forum signature.
2. Spam: just don't do it. Thou also shalt not fill the forums with multiple threads on the same topic or sockpuppet.
3. Thou shalt not flame, harass, denigrate, spam, malign, or otherwise finger-point and name-call at ANYONE. This one's a biggy. This too can get you banned.
4. Squidstaff love interacting with smart front-line people, so they stop by the forums from time to time to hear your ideas and share updates. However, this isn't the place to post bugs or solicit admin action. Please send those requests through our feedback link.
5. The SquidU forum is a place for users to interact, to share ideas and inspiration (and yes, gripes... maybe another lensmaster can help) and have fun with their lenses. Try searching for an answer or visiting The Answer Deck.

#1 03/28/2009 4:33 am

ok4444
Got yer sea legs
From: BKK
Registered: 12/31/1969
Posts: 50

Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Hi guys,
                      I have only one lens at squidoo (in my signature below), It ranks No. 29 in SEO category. Now, I noticed that my lens started shooting up in the ranking when the No. of back-links to it were increasing. Although I have received 5star ranking from many people, got almost 2 dozen comments and 13 fans from a single lens (in just 2 weeks). I feel that the lens rank is most Dependant on back-links, much more than all these factors. Do you agree?

take care

Offline

 

#2 03/28/2009 5:42 am

Greekgeek
Indubitably tentacular
From: Orange County, CA
Registered: 05/04/2007
Posts: 3358

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

It sounds appealing -- but I'm afraid I'm not convinced!

You mentioned several factors that Squidoo HQ, the dashboard stats, and my recent conversion experiment all prove are contributing factors. So it's hard to tell what impact, if any, backlinks have in addition to those "known" factors.

One big clue about lensrank is to look at what Squidoo measures on the dashboard! It synchs very closely with what little HQ has told us:
-- Do you get visitor traffic? How much?
-- Do people interact with and click on the lens? (Guestbook counts)
-- Did you drive any sales?
-- Has anyone rated, favorited, or lensrolled your lens?
--  Do you get traffic from search engines? Many different kinds?
and so on.

The theme here is results. Backlinks are only important to Squidoo, the company and the website, to the extent that they actually bring visitors to the site. But every backlink tool finds a different number of links, whereas Squidoo knows exactly how many people have actually landed on your lens. It makes sense that they measure and reward performance within Squidoo's boundaries, rather than what goes on beyond them.

Last edited by Greekgeek (03/28/2009 5:53 am)

Offline

 

#3 03/28/2009 5:47 am

Chadrew
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: Lithuania
Registered: 03/11/2007
Posts: 1286

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Lensrank does not depend on the backlinks directly (I think), but if backlinks increase your search engine rankings, and that gives you more visitors, then they might affect your lensrank in this way.

Offline

 

#4 03/28/2009 5:56 am

ok4444
Got yer sea legs
From: BKK
Registered: 12/31/1969
Posts: 50

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

so, is it that back-links play no role at all? and should i conclude from this that the no. of visitors are the most important factor for a good squidoo ranking?

Last edited by ok4444 (03/28/2009 6:01 am)

Offline

 

#5 03/28/2009 6:08 am

RickPhillips
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: georgia
Registered: 03/21/2006
Posts: 1275

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

If ten attributes have weight - it is likely that traffic has the most.


Alan Guth, Edmund Husserl, `Bucky' Fuller - Real Thinkers

Offline

 

#6 03/28/2009 6:17 am

Janet21
Citizen Squid Alumni

From: Birthday Party Central
Registered: 01/05/2007
Posts: 2734

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

RickPhillips wrote:

If ten attributes have weight - it is likely that traffic has the most.

So, what would you say has the second most weight - earnings or clickouts?

Last edited by Janet21 (03/28/2009 8:38 am)

Offline

 

#7 03/28/2009 7:32 am

oneskms
Positively aquatic
From: UK
Registered: 07/07/2007
Posts: 344

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

I don't think backlinks have direct weight for lensrank although they (imo) have to have indirect weight by affecting the factors squidoo take into account. I would suggest the main factors go hand in hand with each other, traffic which (hopefully) creates clickouts (and possibly backlinks) which creates sales. The interacting visitor creates fresh content (by commenting which I believe is picked up for seo) or rating or lensrolling (another backlink I think) so really traffic is the main player but for indirect reasons I think. As for the weight of each attribute -  probably only HQ know and there is probably lots of attributes

Offline

 

#8 03/28/2009 8:12 am

mysticmama
Citizen Squid Alumni

From: St. Paul MN
Registered: 12/31/1969
Posts: 2517

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

I have one high ranking lens that had no back links at all when it shot up into the top 100...I have others that didn't start ranking until back-links were in place and I started getting outside traffic...I have some low ranking lenses that get high traffic and some high ranking lenses that get low traffic...
So I doubt very much that lens rank depends on any one factor, but rather depends on a combination of factors... Oh and as far as click-outs go...My lenses were ranking well long before I had any clickouts...in fact my #1 has very few options for even being able to click-out and is the type of lens that no one would want to click out of anyway...
Lens rank is most likely a combination of variables set in place purposely, to make it hard for any one person to find any one way to monopolize the highest ranks...that way quality lenses with lower traffic can rank high along with high traffic sales lenses smile

Offline

 

#9 03/28/2009 8:23 am

MobyD
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: Portland, OR
Registered: 10/19/2007
Posts: 1425

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

ok4444 wrote:

so, is it that back-links play no role at all? and should i conclude from this that the no. of visitors are the most important factor for a good squidoo ranking?

Backlinks help create traffic. Therefore, if you get good backlinks, you'll get more traffic. If you get a lot of backlinks from sites that don't get much traffic themselves, then they might not drive much traffic, so it isn't just the raw number of backlinks that count, it's the quality of the backlinks.

Quality could be defined as being relevant to your lens and also how much traffic is generated. A website that gets only 100 visitors a day might be of better quality than one that gets 1,000 visitors if the site with the lower number of visitors is more closely related to your lens' topic and as a result drives more traffic to your lens.

Offline

 

#10 03/28/2009 8:24 am

RickPhillips
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: georgia
Registered: 03/21/2006
Posts: 1275

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Janet --- I should say first that I think the weights get shifted almost at whim -- in other words -- perhaps during the selling season they weight most the lenses with sales --- at other times of lower squidoo metrics - feature the lenses with the most interaction (clickouts) etc. So, that said, I'd say based on observation only that probably clickouts/per visitor is right up there.


Alan Guth, Edmund Husserl, `Bucky' Fuller - Real Thinkers

Offline

 

#11 03/28/2009 9:47 am

Cinetech
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: Montreal
Registered: 12/31/1969
Posts: 1488

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Backlinks don't seem to have a direct effect in Squidoo LR.
Namely, the number of backlinks don't factor into the LR algorithm.
The referral traffic, that those backlinks bring to the lens, IS what it seem to count the most.

Re: weight of other factors.
- The most dramatic effect seems to come from Freshness.
- Internal Squidoo traffic seems to count more than SE traffic.
- Time spent on lens (see lens below) or interaction has a strong weight as well.
- Squidcasting is the new kid on the block.

Offline

 

#12 03/28/2009 10:10 am

aj2008
Indubitably tentacular
From: England
Registered: 12/31/1969
Posts: 3770

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Cinetech wrote:

Re: weight of other factors.
- The most dramatic effect seems to come from Freshness.
- Internal Squidoo traffic seems to count more than SE traffic.

If that was the case then I have a lens that should be a lot higher up the rankings than it is.

Clickouts play a large part in Lensrank methinks. Those of us who have lenses that can only possibly be of interest to lensmasters struggle to maintain a decent lensrank, despite getting regular traffic, which is why I don't publish many "How to Squidoo" lenses.


Organising the Squidoo Answer Deck

How to Research Keywords | Squidoo Induction

Do's and Dont's on Squidoo: Squid Etiquette

Offline

 

#13 03/28/2009 10:56 pm

Greekgeek
Indubitably tentacular
From: Orange County, CA
Registered: 05/04/2007
Posts: 3358

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Here's an interesting tidbit to ponder.

I was checking traffic sources for one of my lenses, and stumbled across this link:

http://www.squidoo.com/browse/top_lenses/traffic

It's exactly the same list as the Top 100 Lenses, but instead of saying /lensrank at the end it says /traffic.

I guess that confirms what one of the most significant factors is!

Although it's still not THE factor, because I know of lensmasters who get weekly traffic in the thousands, whereas my best are in the hundreds. (Although I just hit 978 on one... c'mon, c'mon, you can do it! -- which, incidentally, ranks less well than my lenses getting 100-500 visitors.)

Last edited by Greekgeek (03/28/2009 10:58 pm)

Offline

 

#14 03/28/2009 11:34 pm

jeffryv
Citizen Squid Alumni

From: Vancouver BC Canada
Registered: 11/17/2005
Posts: 2103

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Greekgeek wrote:

Here's an interesting tidbit to ponder.

I was checking traffic sources for one of my lenses, and stumbled across this link:

http://www.squidoo.com/browse/top_lenses/traffic

It's exactly the same list as the Top 100 Lenses, but instead of saying /lensrank at the end it says /traffic.

I guess that confirms what one of the most significant factors is!

Although it's still not THE factor, because I know of lensmasters who get weekly traffic in the thousands, whereas my best are in the hundreds. (Although I just hit 978 on one... c'mon, c'mon, you can do it! -- which, incidentally, ranks less well than my lenses getting 100-500 visitors.)

Here is some history for you Greekgeek smile
Screenshot from early 2006
http://img9.imageshack.us/img9/4427/top100list.jpg

Offline

 

#15 03/29/2009 3:47 am

RickPhillips
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: georgia
Registered: 03/21/2006
Posts: 1275

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Ah, the days of the most profitable list -- the one I made a lens about after doing research on the list.

One of the funny things is that on that lens, where I show the techniques of the most profitable -- one of the lenses was Attila the Hun -- so I suggested that someone make a lens on Al Capone -- and guess what -- the person who did and the lens that is Al Capone is one of the continuing high rankers around here.

Of course I had imitation lenses for each of the top 10 most profitable --- all this findable thru my Lensmaster name.


Alan Guth, Edmund Husserl, `Bucky' Fuller - Real Thinkers

Offline

 

#16 03/29/2009 10:24 am

kiwisoutback
Mesonychoteuthis
From: Massachusetts
Registered: 10/22/2007
Posts: 980

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Traffic definitely matters the most, but those clickouts have to play an important role.  I have some lower traffic lenses that get high clickouts that outperform some of my much higher traffic lenses on a regular basis. Kind of irritating, actually, because some of those I didn't spend much time on! The star ratings don't seem to have as much of a boost in comparison to a say, 30 clickouts.

Offline

 

#17 03/29/2009 10:37 am

Cinetech
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: Montreal
Registered: 12/31/1969
Posts: 1488

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

kiwisoutback wrote:

Traffic definitely matters the most, but those clickouts have to play an important role.  I have some lower traffic lenses that get high clickouts that outperform some of my much higher traffic lenses on a regular basis.

Kiwi, you just actually said with your example that Clickouts matter more than traffic. smile
Which I agree somehow.
Engaging events (interactions), not just clickouts, is what matter the most.

Offline

 

#18 03/29/2009 11:25 am

ariding
Swimming pretty (100+ posts!)
Registered: 09/17/2007
Posts: 103

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

I am kind of new here and enjoy learning from all of you.  It seems to me though that the more backlinks you have the more chance for traffic you have.  Which leads to the more chance for clickouts, sales, comments and other interaction with the viewers you have.

Offline

 

#19 03/29/2009 12:23 pm

Petee
Swimming pretty (100+ posts!)
Registered: 06/23/2007
Posts: 184

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Chadrew wrote:

Lensrank does not depend on the backlinks directly (I think), but if backlinks increase your search engine rankings, and that gives you more visitors, then they might affect your lensrank in this way.

Well have to agree a bit here.  Some things I have noticed.

Backlinks help with lens rank but traffic seems to be the deciding factor.

PR is determined by backlinks.  PR does not determine lensrank both systems use different criteria.

Lensrank has little effect on SERPS

That being said it is best to get backlinks for traffic and PR will most likely help in the SERPS.

Offline

 

#20 03/29/2009 1:36 pm

kiwisoutback
Mesonychoteuthis
From: Massachusetts
Registered: 10/22/2007
Posts: 980

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Cinetech wrote:

kiwisoutback wrote:

Traffic definitely matters the most, but those clickouts have to play an important role.  I have some lower traffic lenses that get high clickouts that outperform some of my much higher traffic lenses on a regular basis.

Kiwi, you just actually said with your example that Clickouts matter more than traffic. smile
Which I agree somehow.
Engaging events (interactions), not just clickouts, is what matter the most.

I guess I contradicted myself! That's what I get for drinking decaf. I thought I read somewhere on this forum that guestbook comments weren't figured into the algorithm. hmm

Last edited by kiwisoutback (03/29/2009 1:39 pm)

Offline

 

#21 03/29/2009 1:45 pm

thefluffanutta
Citizen Squid Alumni

From: York, England SquidUtils.com
Registered: 09/04/2006
Posts: 7185

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Greekgeek wrote:

I was checking traffic sources for one of my lenses, and stumbled across this link:

http://www.squidoo.com/browse/top_lenses/traffic

It's exactly the same list as the Top 100 Lenses, but instead of saying /lensrank at the end it says /traffic.

The Top 100 Lenses by Traffic doesn't actually exist. You are seeing the Top 100 by Lensrank instead. Many of the other lists that Jeffry, for example Most Profitable, also don't exist.

Greekgeek wrote:

I guess that confirms what one of the most significant factors is!

No, it confirms nothing, though Traffic is an important factor, next to rating, faves, blessings, revenue and clickouts. Meanwhile, Backlinks and Guestbook comments are not part of the Lensrank algorithm.

Offline

 

#22 03/29/2009 3:53 pm

jeffryv
Citizen Squid Alumni

From: Vancouver BC Canada
Registered: 11/17/2005
Posts: 2103

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

thefluffanutta wrote:

Backlinks and Guestbook comments are not part of the Lensrank algorithm.

Totally agree!

Offline

 

#23 03/29/2009 4:09 pm

Greekgeek
Indubitably tentacular
From: Orange County, CA
Registered: 05/04/2007
Posts: 3358

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Oops. Didn't realize that "Top 100 by Traffic" list was no longer actually measuring traffic.

You know what, Fluff? I know you're right, because you actually look at the code, and besides, my own observations have corroborated it. But check out the Squidoo FAQ on lensrank:

"We look at community ratings, lensmaster reputation, clickthrough rates, frequency of updates, inbound and outbound links, revenue generated, and lots of other factors and give the lens a number."

What do they mean by "inbound links"? I don't believe it means backlinks... there's no good way to measure them. I'm guessing they mean how many different links have sent people to the lens. So for example, traffic sent from 12 different sources is counted as more significant than traffic from the same source (e.g. one's SquidU sig).  But ok4444 could argue, "See, I told you so!" based on that ambiguous statement!

Personally I think Squidoo is very straightforward about what factors it counts towards lensrank. They're all on  your main lens stats and traffic tab. I can't prove it, but I betcha that's most of the list. (commissions, traffic sources (ones that sent actual visitors, not just backlinks which might), clickthroughs, favorites, how many different parts of the web pie are sending you traffic, star ratings, visitors, how many times lenses have been emailed -- an oft-forgotten stat -- and most recent update.) The only question is which factors are weighted most.

And rather than weighing that question too much, I say, get back to woik and make some nice lenses! smile

Offline

 

#24 03/29/2009 5:18 pm

Cinetech
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: Montreal
Registered: 12/31/1969
Posts: 1488

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

Greekgeek wrote:

What do they mean by "inbound links"? I don't believe it means backlinks...

Yup, it's the same thing, "inbound links" = backlinks.
Inbound links translate into referral traffic, which is what Squidoo is more interested in.
I agree, you get more points from different sources than just one source.
And based on my observations, internal Squidoo traffic is even more valuable.

Greekgeek wrote:

Personally I think Squidoo is very straightforward about what factors it counts towards lensrank. They're all on  your main lens stats and traffic tab. I can't prove it, but I betcha that's most of the list. (commissions, traffic sources (ones that sent actual visitors, not just backlinks which might), clickthroughs, favorites, how many different parts of the web pie are sending you traffic, star ratings, visitors, how many times lenses have been emailed -- an oft-forgotten stat -- and most recent update.) The only question is which factors are weighted most.

Even if you guess what the weights are or what factors are more important,
they're never going to remain the same. They will be changed and re-shuffled all over again.
The only thing you can control is making quality lenses.

Offline

 

#25 03/29/2009 6:32 pm

The_Book_Garden
Wow. Over 1000 posts.
From: Bristol, UK
Registered: 06/30/2007
Posts: 1068

Re: Squidoo Rank depends on backlinks?

ok4444 wrote:

Hi guys,
                      I have only one lens at squidoo (in my signature below), It ranks No. 29 in SEO category. Now, I noticed that my lens started shooting up in the ranking when the No. of back-links to it were increasing. Although I have received 5star ranking from many people, got almost 2 dozen comments and 13 fans from a single lens (in just 2 weeks). I feel that the lens rank is most Dependant on back-links, much more than all these factors. Do you agree?

take care

Errrr.......Didn't we just have a very similair conversation very recently - One Lesson That Sky Rocketed my Lens - In 2 Days. Must Read!


I'd say the biggest factor therefore is surely including a signature link in forum posts hinting you have the secret to success and are willing to share it, double whammy if you also hint at this in a topic title you start!!  Especially if it happens to be a squidoo related forum, thereby getting lensmasters to come view and comment on your lens by making controversial posts in forums !!

wink

Offline

 

Board footer

Powered by PunBB
© Copyright 2002–2005 Rickard Andersson